added a star repo modal #1492
Closed
added a star repo modal #1492
Conversation
This file contains bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
WalkthroughThe pull request introduces a new feature to the Sidebar component that adds a promotional section encouraging users to star the Checkmate GitHub repository. The implementation includes a state-managed, dismissible box that can be hidden permanently using local storage. The feature aims to increase project visibility and user engagement by providing a simple, unobtrusive prompt to star the project on GitHub. Changes
Assessment against linked issues
The changes align closely with the issue's primary requirements, providing a mechanism to encourage repository stars while allowing user dismissal. Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
Documentation and Community
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (1)
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx (1)
525-561: Hype it up, but watch out for user fatigue.
The star repo prompt is well-designed and user-friendly. However, keep in mind potential over-promotion that might disturb some users. Encouraging them to star the repo is brilliant for building community, but ensure easy dismissal. You’re golden here: just watch future expansions in case you need more spacing or theming synergy.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
package-lock.jsonis excluded by!**/package-lock.json
📒 Files selected for processing (1)
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx(4 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (4)
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx (4)
47-47: This import hits the spot, no spaghetti falling off.
All good here, mate! The new icon import from MUI is looking proper and helps keep your code consistent.
123-123: Nice move setting that state!
This new showStarRepo state variable is a slick approach, ensuring the star box can be toggled without messing up the rest of the UI.
161-167: Double-check your localStorage read before the beat drops.
Your useEffect logic is correct, but consider verifying any potential edge cases if localStorage is blocked or unavailable in a privacy scenario. Otherwise, arms aren’t heavy here—rhymes are smooth.
168-171: No more sweaty palms, ditch that star box gracefully.
Your handleCloseStarRepo method does a tidy job of tucking away the modal and logging a little record in local storage. Perfect for a persistent dismissal.
![llamapreview[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1023541?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Auto Pull Request Review from LlamaPReview
1. Overview
1.1 PR Summary
- Business value and requirements alignment: The PR fixes issue Add a modal to encourage starring the Checkmate repo #1484 by adding a star repo modal, encouraging users to star the Checkmate repository on GitHub. This aligns with the business requirement of increasing the project's visibility and community engagement.
- Key components modified: The PR modifies the
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsxfile, adding a new modal component to the sidebar. - Impact assessment: The PR has a moderate impact, as it changes the user interface and user experience by adding a new modal component. It also introduces a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly.
- System dependencies and integration impacts: The PR introduces a new dependency on local storage to remember the user's preference. It also integrates with the GitHub API to display the number of stars for the Checkmate repository.
1.2 Architecture Changes
- System design modifications: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which is a significant architectural change as it affects the user interface and user experience.
- Component interactions: The modal interacts with the local storage to remember if the user has closed the star repo modal. It also contains a link to the GitHub repository, which could potentially expose the application to security risks if not properly sanitized or validated.
- Integration points: The modal integrates with the GitHub API to display the number of stars for the Checkmate repository. It also integrates with the local storage to remember the user's preference.
2. Detailed Technical Analysis
2.1 Code Logic Deep-Dive
Core Logic Changes
-
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx -
handleCloseStarRepofunction- Submitted PR Code:
const handleCloseStarRepo = () => { setShowStarRepo(false); localStorage.setItem("starRepoClosed", "true"); };
- Analysis:
- The
handleCloseStarRepofunction is responsible for closing the star repo modal and storing the user's preference in local storage. - The current logic uses
localStorage.setItemto store the user's preference, which is a simple and effective way to remember the user's choice across sessions. However, it does not handle the case where the user clears their browser data or uses multiple devices. - Edge cases and error handling: The function does not handle any errors that might occur when trying to set the item in local storage. If an error occurs, the user's preference will not be stored, and the modal might reappear unexpectedly.
- Cross-component impact: The function uses local storage to store the user's preference, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly.
- The
- LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:
const handleCloseStarRepo = async () => { try { setShowStarRepo(false); await localStorage.setItem("starRepoClosed", "true"); } catch (error) { console.error("Error storing user preference:", error); } };
- Improvement rationale:
- Adding
async/awaitto the function allows for better error handling and ensures that the user's preference is stored even if an error occurs. - Using
try/catchblocks to handle any errors that might occur when trying to set the item in local storage. This ensures that the user's preference is stored even if an error occurs. - Technical benefits: Better error handling and ensuring that the user's preference is stored even if an error occurs.
- Business value: Ensuring that the user's preference is stored and respected, even if an error occurs.
- Risk assessment: Low risk, as the improvement only affects the error handling of the function and does not introduce any new dependencies or behaviors.
- Adding
- Submitted PR Code:
-
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx -
useEffecthook for local storage- Submitted PR Code:
useEffect(() => { const hasClosed = localStorage.getItem("starRepoClosed"); if (hasClosed) { setShowStarRepo(false); } }, []);
- Analysis:
- The
useEffecthook is responsible for retrieving the user's preference from local storage and setting theshowStarRepostate variable accordingly. - The current logic uses
localStorage.getItemto retrieve the user's preference, which is a simple and effective way to remember the user's choice across sessions. However, it does not handle the case where the user clears their browser data or uses multiple devices. - Edge cases and error handling: The hook does not handle any errors that might occur when trying to get the item from local storage. If an error occurs, the
showStarRepostate variable will not be set correctly, and the modal might appear unexpectedly. - Business logic considerations: The hook should also consider the case where the user has never seen the modal before. In this case, the
showStarRepostate variable should be set totrue.
- The
- LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:
useEffect(() => { const getUserPreference = async () => { try { const hasClosed = await localStorage.getItem("starRepoClosed"); if (hasClosed) { setShowStarRepo(false); } else { setShowStarRepo(true); } } catch (error) { console.error("Error retrieving user preference:", error); setShowStarRepo(true); // Default to showing the modal if an error occurs } }; getUserPreference(); }, []);
- Improvement rationale:
- Adding
async/awaitto theuseEffecthook allows for better error handling and ensures that theshowStarRepostate variable is set correctly even if an error occurs. - Using
try/catchblocks to handle any errors that might occur when trying to get the item from local storage. This ensures that theshowStarRepostate variable is set correctly even if an error occurs. - Considering the case where the user has never seen the modal before and setting the
showStarRepostate variable totruein this case. - Technical benefits: Better error handling and ensuring that the
showStarRepostate variable is set correctly even if an error occurs. - Business value: Ensuring that the user's preference is respected and that the modal behaves as expected even if an error occurs.
- Risk assessment: Low risk, as the improvement only affects the error handling of the
useEffecthook and does not introduce any new dependencies or behaviors.
- Adding
- Submitted PR Code:
-
Client/src/Components/Sidebar/index.jsx -
showStarRepostate variable- Submitted PR Code:
const [showStarRepo, setShowStarRepo] = useState(true);
- Analysis:
- The
showStarRepostate variable is responsible for determining whether the star repo modal is shown or not. - The current logic initializes the state variable to
true, which means that the modal will be shown by default. However, this might not be the desired behavior, as the user might have already closed the modal in a previous session. - Edge cases and error handling: The current logic does not consider the case where the user has already closed the modal in a previous session. In this case, the modal might be shown unexpectedly.
- Business logic considerations: The
showStarRepostate variable should be initialized to the user's preference, which can be retrieved from local storage.
- The
- LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:
const [showStarRepo, setShowStarRepo] = useState(() => { const hasClosed = localStorage.getItem("starRepoClosed"); return hasClosed ? false : true; });
- Improvement rationale:
- Initializing the
showStarRepostate variable to the user's preference, which can be retrieved from local storage. This ensures that the modal behaves as expected even if the user has already closed it in a previous session. - Technical benefits: Ensuring that the
showStarRepostate variable is initialized to the user's preference. - Business value: Ensuring that the modal behaves as expected even if the user has already closed it in a previous session.
- Risk assessment: Low risk, as the improvement only affects the initialization of the
showStarRepostate variable and does not introduce any new dependencies or behaviors.
- Initializing the
- Submitted PR Code:
2.2 Implementation Quality
- Code organization and structure: The PR maintains a clear and organized structure, with the new modal component added to the sidebar. The code is well-commented and follows the existing coding conventions.
- Design patterns usage: The PR uses the Material-UI library to style the modal component, which is a common design pattern for React applications.
- Error handling approach: The PR introduces a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. The PR also introduces a new dependency on the GitHub API, which could potentially lead to security risks if not properly sanitized or validated.
- Resource management: The PR does not introduce any new resources that need to be managed. However, it does introduce a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly.
3. Critical Findings
3.1 Potential Issues
-
🔴 Critical Issues
- Local storage usage: The PR uses local storage to remember the user's preference, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. The PR does not handle the case where the user clears their browser data or uses multiple devices.
- Impact: The modal might appear unexpectedly or not appear at all if the user clears their browser data or uses multiple devices.
- Recommendation: Implement a more robust solution for remembering the user's preference, such as using a backend service to store the user's preference in a database.
- Link sanitization: The PR contains a direct link to the GitHub repository, which could potentially expose the application to cross-site scripting (XSS) attacks if not properly sanitized.
- Impact: The application could be vulnerable to XSS attacks if the link is not properly sanitized.
- Recommendation: Sanitize the link to the GitHub repository to prevent potential XSS attacks.
- Local storage usage: The PR uses local storage to remember the user's preference, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. The PR does not handle the case where the user clears their browser data or uses multiple devices.
-
🟡 Warnings
- Modal performance: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which could potentially impact the performance of the application if not properly optimized.
- Potential risks: The modal could slow down the application's loading time or cause it to become unresponsive if not properly optimized.
- Suggested improvements: Optimize the modal component to ensure that it does not negatively impact the application's performance. This could include lazy-loading the modal component or using a more efficient rendering method.
- Modal performance: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which could potentially impact the performance of the application if not properly optimized.
3.2 Code Quality Concerns
- Maintainability aspects: The PR maintains a high level of maintainability, with clear and organized code that is well-commented and follows existing coding conventions.
- Readability issues: The PR is well-documented and follows best practices for code readability, making it easy for other developers to understand and maintain.
- Performance bottlenecks: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which could potentially impact the performance of the application if not properly optimized. However, the PR does not introduce any new performance bottlenecks.
4. Security Assessment
- Authentication/Authorization impacts: The PR does not introduce any new authentication or authorization requirements.
- Data handling concerns: The PR introduces a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. The PR also introduces a new dependency on the GitHub API, which could potentially lead to security risks if not properly sanitized or validated.
- Input validation: The PR does not introduce any new input validation requirements.
- Security best practices: The PR follows best practices for security, such as using HTTPS to secure the connection to the GitHub API.
- Potential security risks: The PR introduces a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. The PR also introduces a new dependency on the GitHub API, which could potentially lead to security risks if not properly sanitized or validated.
- Mitigation strategies: Implement a more robust solution for remembering the user's preference, such as using a backend service to store the user's preference in a database. Sanitize the link to the GitHub repository to prevent potential XSS attacks.
- Security testing requirements: Conduct security testing to ensure that the modal does not expose the application to any security risks.
5. Testing Strategy
5.1 Test Coverage
- Unit test analysis: The PR does not introduce any new unit tests. However, it does introduce a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly.
- Integration test requirements: Conduct integration testing to ensure that the modal integrates properly with the local storage and the GitHub API.
- Edge cases coverage: Test the modal with different user preferences and ensure that it behaves as expected in all cases. Test the modal with different browser data settings and ensure that it behaves as expected in all cases.
5.2 Test Recommendations
Suggested Test Cases
// Test case for local storage usage
it("should not show the modal if the user has closed it in a previous session", () => {
localStorage.setItem("starRepoClosed", "true");
render(<Sidebar />);
expect(screen.queryByTestId("star-repo-modal")).not.toBeInTheDocument();
});
// Test case for link sanitization
it("should sanitize the link to the GitHub repository", () => {
render(<Sidebar />);
const link = screen.getByTestId("github-link");
expect(link).toHaveAttribute("href", "https://github.com/bluewave-labs/checkmate");
expect(link).toHaveAttribute("target", "_blank");
expect(link).toHaveAttribute("rel", "noopener noreferrer");
});- Coverage improvements: Conduct code coverage analysis to ensure that the modal component is properly tested.
- Performance testing needs: Conduct performance testing to ensure that the modal does not negatively impact the application's performance.
6. Documentation & Maintenance
- Documentation updates needed: Update the documentation to reflect the changes made to the sidebar component.
- Long-term maintenance considerations: The PR introduces a new dependency on local storage, which could potentially lead to data loss or inconsistencies if not handled properly. Consider using a backend service to store the user's preference in a database for better long-term maintenance.
- Technical debt and monitoring requirements: Monitor the modal component to ensure that it does not introduce any new technical debt or performance issues.
7. Deployment & Operations
- Deployment impact and strategy: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which will be visible to all users of the Checkmate tool. Deploy the PR to the production environment with minimal downtime.
- Key operational considerations: Monitor the modal component to ensure that it does not introduce any new operational issues or performance bottlenecks.
8. Summary & Recommendations
8.1 Key Action Items
- Critical changes required: Implement a more robust solution for remembering the user's preference, such as using a backend service to store the user's preference in a database. Sanitize the link to the GitHub repository to prevent potential XSS attacks.
- Important improvements suggested: Optimize the modal component to ensure that it does not negatively impact the application's performance. Conduct integration testing to ensure that the modal integrates properly with the local storage and the GitHub API. Conduct security testing to ensure that the modal does not expose the application to any security risks.
- Best practices to implement: Follow best practices for security, such as using HTTPS to secure the connection to the GitHub API. Conduct code coverage analysis to ensure that the modal component is properly tested.
- Cross-cutting concerns to address: Monitor the modal component to ensure that it does not introduce any new technical debt or performance issues.
8.2 Future Considerations
- Technical evolution path: Consider using a backend service to store the user's preference in a database for better long-term maintenance. Consider using a more efficient rendering method for the modal component to improve performance.
- Business capability evolution: The PR introduces a new modal component to the sidebar, which could potentially impact the user experience. Conduct user acceptance testing to ensure that the modal is user-friendly and does not negatively impact the user experience.
- System integration impacts: The PR introduces a new dependency on the GitHub API, which could potentially lead to security risks if not properly sanitized or validated. Consider using a more secure method for integrating with the GitHub API, such as using a backend service to proxy the API requests.
💡 Help Shape LlamaPReview
How's this review format working for you? Vote in our Github Discussion Polls to help us improve your review experience!
Thank you for your contribution. This has already been assigned and probably the developer is working on it. You can remove your PR for now and wait for a couple of days for the assigned developer to see if it's resolved. Sorry about that. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi Dikshit! Thanks for your effort.
Since the Client and Server has separate dependencies in their directories we don't need package-lock.json file in the root directory. I think it comes from wrongly used npm install command, you can remove it.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Indeed, please remove this pacakge-lock.json file.
ajhollid
requested changes
Dec 31, 2024
| <Typography style={{ fontStyle: "bold" , marginTop: "5px",color: "black" , fontSize: "16px" }} variant="body2" color="black"> | ||
| Star Checkmate | ||
| </Typography> | ||
| <Typography style={{ fontSize: "13px" , marginTop: "10px" , color: "black" }} variant="body2" color="black"> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hardcoded values, especially font sizes and colors, are inhernetly not maintainable.
Please refactor to make use of the theme.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Indeed, please remove this pacakge-lock.json file.
|
Closing this PR as inactive |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
I have fixed the #1484 issue by adding a star repo modal
here is how it looks :
fixed #1484