Alexa volume not adjustable by voice command, Assistant comparatively too quiet

[rsuhendro]

Python 2 & 3 releases (python2 --version and python3 --version):

**Python 2.7.9 & Python 3.4.2**

Description of problem:

The voice output level of Google Assistant is too low. Sometimes the hotword **Google** was also missed, no triggering.

Expected:

The same level as the AlexaPi.

Steps to reproduce:

Traceback (if applicable):

Additional info:

Run on RPI 3 with Raspbian Jessie Lite. I use PulseAudio in the config.yaml because for unknown reason I can't make AlexaPi works with ALSA.
I've set the volume level using alsamixer. 

[xtools-at]

Hi,

have you tried setting the output volume by using Google's and Alexa's native voice commands? For Alexa, this works (it starts with a default of ~80%). The Google SDK, which AssistantPi uses, claims to suport voice control for volume, but I haven't tested it yet.

Just fyi, AssistantPi defaults to using pulseaudio since release 1.0 and does all necessary settings during the setup.

[rsuhendro]

I've tried to reduce default_volume to 40% in config.yaml but Alexa is still loud. I can't find the volume control command for Google SDK.
Any hints?

[AISense-UTM]

Same issue with a RPI 2, has anyone been able to increase the volume for Google SDK. It is way too low if compare with Alexa.

[bote795]

found the voice command to increase googles voice, https://support.google.com/googlehome/answer/7072489?hl=en

[rsuhendro]

Thanks. It works. I can set max volume (level 10). But somehow Alexa is still louder, so I need to find a way to lower it.

[xtools-at]

Sorry, I've been out of town for some days - you can adjust Alexa's volume with it's native voice command, simply say "Alexa, louder/softer" or "Alexa, Voume 4"
https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=201619520

[rsuhendro]

Just perfect...fully solved. Thanks a lot.

[xtools-at]

It seems that adjusting Alexa's volume isn't working properly (RPi Zero W). I get the message in debug mode, that volume has been adjusted, but there's no difference between 2 and 10... Anyone else experiencing this issue?

[wpa-2]

I am also facing the same issue, no matter what i try alexa i always so much louder. The volume doesnt seem to change.

I also have an issue with google activating at almost any word, even if its the tv it activates and starts talking.

Great work though.

[rsuhendro]

Yes the command works: Volume 4

2017-06-18 22:38:51 DEBUG: JSON String Returned: {
  "messageBody": {
    "directives": [
      {
        "namespace": "Speaker", 
        "name": "SetVolume", 
        "payload": {
          "volume": 40, 
          "adjustmentType": "absolute"
        }
      }
    ]
  }, 
  "messageHeader": {}
}
2017-06-18 22:38:51 DEBUG: Setting volume to: 40
2017-06-18 22:38:51 DEBUG: new volume = 40

But the voice level is as loud as before..

[xtools-at]

tried to hack around this problem by setting the system volume via subprocess/pexpect using amixer -D pulse sset Master 50%, but it seems to have no effect on the daemon, even if it runs in the same scope (i.e. run by service, not manually by a Linux user account). Anyone any ideas on this?