diff --git a/src/Certify.Providers/ACME/Anvil/AnvilACMEProvider.cs b/src/Certify.Providers/ACME/Anvil/AnvilACMEProvider.cs
index 13f7fc624..8b2565ee9 100644
--- a/src/Certify.Providers/ACME/Anvil/AnvilACMEProvider.cs
+++ b/src/Certify.Providers/ACME/Anvil/AnvilACMEProvider.cs
@@ -821,7 +821,7 @@ public async Task<PendingOrder> BeginCertificateOrder(ILog log, ManagedCertifica
                                     && managedCertificate.CertificateCurrentCA == managedCertificate.LastAttemptedCA
                                     && !string.IsNullOrWhiteSpace(managedCertificate.ARICertificateId)
                                     && managedCertificate.ARICertificateId.Contains(".")
-                                    && managedCertificate.RenewalFailureCount < 3
+                                    && managedCertificate.RenewalFailureCount == 0
                                     && !skipAriReplace
                                 )
                                 {