Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Set atom/bond type judge option #26

Open
mquevill opened this issue Mar 31, 2021 · 1 comment
Open

Set atom/bond type judge option #26

mquevill opened this issue Mar 31, 2021 · 1 comment

Comments

@mquevill
Copy link

There are several options in Antechamber to guess atom and bond types (using the -j flag). Some of these only work with certain charge methods, such as bcc will change prediction types <4 to 4 (but 5 will still work).

I have seen Antechamber "fail" with some charged species because of some of the atom/bond assignments. Since mol2 files contain bond types, these don't necessarily need to be guessed, so the option -j 5 has worked for me in these cases. This will still do partial bond type assignment, but should honor the mol2 bond types for the most part.

Reference for -j:

  • 0: No judgement
  • 1: Atom type
  • 2: Full bond type
  • 3: Partial bond type
  • 4: Atom and full bond type
  • 5: Atom and partial bond type
@mquevill
Copy link
Author

mquevill commented Apr 7, 2021

Take, for example, the anion TFSI. This is a symmetric molecule with two SO2 groups around the central N atom, but the default typing that ACPYPE determines sets the two S atoms differently (s6-ne-sy) than I would expect (sy-n2-sy).

Input file:

@<TRIPOS>MOLECULE
*****
 15 14 0 0 0
SMALL
GASTEIGER

@<TRIPOS>ATOM
      1 F           3.9349   -0.3814    0.2600 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
      2 C           2.7407    0.1128   -0.1917 C.3     1  UNL1        0.4919
      3 F           2.0667   -0.9630   -0.6974 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
      4 F           2.0548    0.4970    0.9253 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
      5 S           2.9408    1.4710   -1.4149 S.O2    1  UNL1       -0.1455
      6 O           2.2350    0.9995   -2.6104 O.2     1  UNL1       -0.2006
      7 O           2.3356    2.6413   -0.7766 O.2     1  UNL1       -0.2006
      8 N           4.5240    1.4542   -1.4983 N.3     1  UNL1        0.0218
      9 S           5.0963    2.5988   -2.4336 S.O2    1  UNL1       -0.1455
     10 O           4.7286    2.5301   -3.8503 O.2     1  UNL1       -0.2006
     11 O           5.0789    3.9505   -1.8674 O.2     1  UNL1       -0.2006
     12 C           6.8648    2.0940   -2.3876 C.3     1  UNL1        0.4919
     13 F           7.0938    1.0224   -1.5667 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
     14 F           7.3466    1.7285   -3.6121 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
     15 F           7.6900    3.0848   -1.9370 F       1  UNL1       -0.1520
@<TRIPOS>BOND
     1     1     2    1
     2     2     3    1
     3     2     4    1
     4     2     5    1
     5     5     6    2
     6     5     7    2
     7     5     8    1
     8     8     9    1
     9     9    10    2
    10     9    11    2
    11     9    12    1
    12    12    13    1
    13    12    14    1
    14    12    15    1

Resulting .itp atom types from running acpype -i tfsi.mol2 -n -1 -o gmx:

[ atoms ]
;   nr  type  resi  res  atom  cgnr     charge      mass       ; qtot   bond_type
     1    f     1   UNL     F    1    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.272
     2   c3     1   UNL     C    2     0.554700     12.01000 ; qtot 0.283
     3    f     1   UNL    F1    3    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot 0.011
     4    f     1   UNL    F2    4    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.260
     5   s6     1   UNL     S    5     1.483700     32.06000 ; qtot 1.224
     6    o     1   UNL     O    6    -0.613200     16.00000 ; qtot 0.610
     7    o     1   UNL    O1    7    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot -0.046
     8   ne     1   UNL     N    8    -1.059100     14.01000 ; qtot -1.106
     9   sy     1   UNL    S1    9     1.679398     32.06000 ; qtot 0.574
    10    o     1   UNL    O2   10    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot -0.083
    11    o     1   UNL    O3   11    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot -0.740
    12   c3     1   UNL    C1   12     0.554700     12.01000 ; qtot -0.185
    13    f     1   UNL    F3   13    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.457
    14    f     1   UNL    F4   14    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.728
    15    f     1   UNL    F5   15    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -1.000

Resulting types after running with adding -j 5 to

cmd = "%s -dr no -i %s -fi %s -o %s -fo mol2 %s -nc %s -m %s -s 2 -df %s -at %s -pf y %s" % (

[ atoms ]
;   nr  type  resi  res  atom  cgnr     charge      mass       ; qtot   bond_type
     1    f     1   UNL     F    1    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.272
     2   c3     1   UNL     C    2     0.554700     12.01000 ; qtot 0.283
     3    f     1   UNL    F1    3    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot 0.011
     4    f     1   UNL    F2    4    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.260
     5   sy     1   UNL     S    5     1.616399     32.06000 ; qtot 1.356
     6    o     1   UNL     O    6    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot 0.699
     7    o     1   UNL    O1    7    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot 0.043
     8   n2     1   UNL     N    8    -1.085200     14.01000 ; qtot -1.043
     9   sy     1   UNL    S1    9     1.616399     32.06000 ; qtot 0.574
    10    o     1   UNL    O2   10    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot -0.083
    11    o     1   UNL    O3   11    -0.656800     16.00000 ; qtot -0.740
    12   c3     1   UNL    C1   12     0.554700     12.01000 ; qtot -0.185
    13    f     1   UNL    F3   13    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.457
    14    f     1   UNL    F4   14    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -0.728
    15    f     1   UNL    F5   15    -0.271633     19.00000 ; qtot -1.000

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant